Volcanic 'avalanches' glide on air, boosting their deadly speed

Pyroclastic flows are a leading cause of eruption-related deaths. Now, lab tests reveal the mind-bending reason they may rush down a volcano’s flanks.

A hot avalanche of gas, ash, and rocks known as a pyroclastic flow travels down the slope of the active Merapi volcano in Central Java, Indonesia.

One of the leading killers during explosive volcanic eruptions is a family of superheated gas, ash, and debris known as pyroclastic density currents. These tumbling, turbulent paroxysms rush downslope at temperatures as high as 1,300°F and at speeds often exceeding 50 miles an hour.

Learning how these hard-to-predict and hard-to-escape currents work is paramount to protecting the communities that live in their potential paths. For instance, many pyroclastic density currents travel further than they should based on our present understanding of physics, with their long reach challenging scientists’ understanding of how they operate.

Now, researchers may have found out why: A new study published today in Nature Geoscience reports that a member of this family, the pyroclastic flow, is able to move so fast and so far because it can glide along on a cushion of air. These concentrated mixtures of fairly fine ash and gas take advantage of this air-lubricated base, which reduces friction during their race down slope, over horizontal surfaces and, if they have enough momentum, even uphill.

Earth 101

Analyzing pyroclastic flows in real life is not only difficult, but also profoundly dangerous. So a team of scientists decided to replicate them in a laboratory using a literal ton of volcanic debris left over from a colossal 2,000-year-old eruptionin New Zealand. They heated up the material and dumped it down a 39-foot-long slide, creating a miniature but startlingly realistic pyroclastic flow.

Using computer simulations to scale their results up to real life flows, the team’s data suggest that this friction-evading mechanism appears during bona fide explosive eruptions.

“This is a great example of how to combine experiments with numerical models to develop a better understanding of complex natural processes,” says Ben Andrews, an experimental volcanologist at the National Museum of Natural History who was not involved in the research.

Internal affairs

The authors of the new study, led by Massey University’s Gert Lube, used a contraption called the Pyroclastic flow Eruption Large-scale Experiment, or PELE, to safely study pyroclastic flows in action. High-speed recordings of the experiment then allowed them to study its evolution in great detail, including the development of the lubricating layer of air.

There is air within a pyroclastic flow. This air has pressure, which is a form of stored energy. As the air at the base of the flow encounters the ground, its kinetic energy increases, but it steals this from its cache of stored energy. As a result, the air at the base of the flow experiences a decrease in pressure. This creates a low-pressure zone at the base and a high-pressure zone above it.

This pressure gradient forces air to migrate from inside the pyroclastic flow to the base, creating a lubricating cushion that separates the flow from the ground. Although it involves a different process, this cushion has the same effect as when an air hockey table reduces the friction on the pucks as they zip around the aerated surface.

This air cushion “makes all the difference,” Lube says, because pyroclastic flows’ internal mixtures have very high friction. Without this lubricating air, “the mixture can’t be any more mobile than a truck-load of sand.”

He notes that this air lubrication mechanism only manifests itself beneath pyroclastic flows. It won’t appear underneath highly dilute, gas-rich pyroclastic surges, another type of pyroclastic density current and the sort that, along with pyroclastic flows, ravaged Pompeii and Herculaneum two millennia ago.

Going against the flow

The new study provides some important data that should be incorporated into how we model these flows, says Rebecca Williams, a volcanologist at the University of Hull.

Lab-based replicas of pyroclastic density currents are becoming increasingly commonplace. “Experiments can only give us snapshots of the real behavior of pyroclastic density currents,” she says, “but each snapshot is important in building up our understanding of these hazardous flows.”

Replicating any pyroclastic density current in a lab is very difficult, but this team’s state-of-the-art experiments advance the field by investigating a wider range of possibilities than ever before, adds Johan Gilchrist, a volcanologist at the University of British Columbia.

However, he notes that several pre-existing studies have offered viable alternative explanations for how the flows travel such great distances, sometimes hundreds of miles from the volcano that birthed them. One idea is that an upward flow of gas through the mixture helps to support debris within it, making it behave more fluidly. As less of the flow’s momentum is taken away by both its internal friction and the friction at its base, it can keep moving forwards longer than it otherwise might.

close

A startling sunset reddens the Lemaire Channel, off the west coast of the Antarctic Peninsula. The continent’s coastal ice is crumbling as the sea and air around it warm. This photo originally published in “The Larsen C Ice Shelf Collapse Is Just the Beginning—Antarctica Is Melting.”

close

A California sea lion hunts for fish on a kelp paddy at Cortes Bank, a seamount off San Diego. It’s a trove of marine life that deserves protection, conservationists say. This photo originally published in “Why It’s Important to Save Our Seas’ Pristine Places.”

close

Inspired by images on Instagram, Jonathan Farrar and Marty Castro ventured outside and discovered a love for nature and camping. They drove up the West Coast, visiting national parks, including Crater Lake in Oregon, the country’s deepest lake. This photo originally published in “Can the Selfie Generation Unplug and Get Into Parks?

close

Furrows of artificial light lend an otherworldly aura to Westland, the greenhouse capital of the Netherlands. Climate-controlled farms such as these grow crops around the clock and in every kind of weather. This photo originally published in “This Tiny Country Feeds the World.”

close

Utah’s Bonneville Salt Flats comprise some 46 square miles of hard, white crust west of Great Salt Lake. The flats and the lake are remnants of Pleistocene-epoch Lake Bonneville. This photo originally published in “Some of the World's Biggest Lakes Are Drying Up. Here's Why.

close

Complex, ever changing patterns of water and land support the bountiful wildlife and vegetation of Botswana’s Okavango Delta. By opening trails that become channels, elephants add to the dynamism. This photo originally published in “Inside the Mission to Save Africa’s Okavango Delta.”

close

The trademark of moorland is heather, a perennial that blooms in shades of pink and white as well as purple. This expanse unfurls down to the Dee River at Mar Lodge Estate in Aberdeenshire. Now owned by the National Trust for Scotland, Mar Lodge is pursuing a program of forest restoration. This photo originally published in “What Will Become of Scotland's Moors?

close

In Gasa, Bhutan, monks play a volleyball match against the local police. This photo originally published in “World's Happiest Country Also Has No Carbon Emissions.”

close

Cemeteries and camps of Afari nomads sit amidst lava flows partially buried in clay near the Awash River Delta in Ethiopia. This photo originally published in “A Photographer's Eye From the Sky.”

close

During a geomagnetic storm, a neon green ribbon of aurora australis danced over Earth in this 2010 photograph taken by an astronaut on the International Space Station. This photo originally published in “20 Stunning Shots of Earth From Space.”

Tap images for captions

In addition, the team’s computer models make some simplifying assumptions, Gilchrist says. Although these new simulations are at the cutting-edge, he says that it’s not entirely clear yet how applicable they are to the largest, most destructive of flows.

For instance, other processes that could affect the flow, like soil erosion, are not taken into account, says Alexis Bougouin, a postdoctoral volcanologist at the University of Clermont-Auvergne. In the end, he says, the air cushion could be one of multiple mechanisms that allows pyroclastic density currents to be very mobile.

These points are “not meant to detract from the authors’ fantastic work and exciting new idea,” Gilchrist says. Rather, they are designed “to inject a dose of healthy skepticism into the debate as to whether or not these experiments and simulation results are accurately reproducing the exact dynamics” of natural pyroclastic flows.

Fingerprints of a killer

As well as refining the models, an important next step would be to go back into the field. It’s possible that a pyroclastic flow running on an air cushion would leave a distinctive geological fingerprint in the deposits they ultimately leave behind. If they do, Gilchrist says, then volcanologists could look for them and help to corroborate the idea that these killer flows glide on air.

The case may not be closed, but Janine Krippner, a volcanologist at the Smithsonian Institution’s Global Volcanism Program, says that this work is nevertheless an “important step forward.”

There are 800 million people living within 60 miles of active volcanoes, “and pyroclastic flows are leading killers of people in these areas,” Krippner says. “All the research we do goes toward helping communities.” 

PUBLISHED

Follow Us

twitter